February 27, 2018 by Andrew Spencer in Book Review
Evidence that Demands a Verdict is a title well known to many Christians. The book was originally published in the early 1970’s by Josh McDowell as a source book for Christian apologetics. It both presents arguments and points readers toward more in-depth arguments for the truthfulness of Christianity.
Given the four decades since the book’s original publication, many of the sources in the first edition are outdated. Over time, arguments change, new evidence for or against positions is considered, and scholars on all sides of the debate reframe their thoughts.
It was high time for this book to be updated. This year, Josh McDowell and his son, Sean, have released an expanded and updated version of this classic work on apologetics. This volume adds the credentials of the younger McDowell to the senior's extensive apologetic experience.The younger McDowell is an apologist, serving on the faculty of Biola University.
About the Book
Evidence that Demands a Verdict is the sort of book that defies concise summary. At over 700 pages, it makes a satisfying thunk when set on the table. That alone may be enough to add gravity to the claims of a budding apologist. It has a helpful table of contents with chapter abstracts, as well as subject and author indices, which keep this tome from being unwieldy.
The arguments are laid out in logical chunks in outline format. This makes the book suitable for research, though it might make cover-to-cover reading more difficult.
The McDowells have covered the major questions of Christian apologetics. They invest five chapters discussing the historical reliability of Scripture. Eight chapters help demonstrate the historicity of Christ and his resurrection. There are thirteen chapters dedicated to the reliability of the Old Testament. The last major section includes six chapters arguing that truth is possible, with an attempt to counter certain claims of postmodernism.
The beauty of this book is that it has been well seasoned over decades and targeted to engage ongoing discussions charitably and at the point of contention. This enables the arguments in this volume to cover a great deal of territory in relatively brief space, which may seem amazing, given the length of the book.
That the authors have covered such broad ranging topics in such a short space is a gift to Christians seeking to understand the major points of the plurality of debates about the truthfulness of Christianity and, hopefully, engage their skeptical friends with the truth of Scripture, especially the gospel. This really is a good, first stop for a number of excellent arguments.
At the same time, the target audience (regular Christians) and the brevity of some of the discussions sets the volume up for its likely criticisms. There is no doubt the war drums of some Christian philosophers will be beaten as they line up to critique some of the interpretations of the volume. For example, the section on postmodernism is an easy target since the subject matter has more publicized versions than the number of scholars that have argued for it. This makes every generalization about the subject a target for critique, and, since many postmodernisms conflict with one another, there is no safe ground to argue against the general drift of thought. (Part of the joy of being postmodern seems to be the ability to say your critics don’t get it as you smile smugly.) If readers accept that the chapters in this volume are introductory and not exhaustive, this book stands up to reasonable scrutiny.
Uses for the Book
It is unlikely that most people will read this volume cover to cover. It is constructed like a reference book and will serve that purpose well.
At the same time, the length of the chapters would make it useful for study with a group of young Christians. It is unlikely any group would make their way through the entirety of the volume. However, it would be a helpful resource to introduce someone to some of the credible arguments for Christianity.
The book might serve well as a secondary volume in an apologetics course at the college or seminary level, with some assigned readings chosen to introduce particular topics. Again, it would be difficult to get through the whole volume in a semester or year.
The most important use of this volume is as a way to self-equip for the ministry of evangelism in a skeptical age. The chapters are useful for buttressing the faith once delivered to all the saints. They are also helpful in showing how to frame an argument against the common objections to Christianity. This is a handy resource for a Christian engaged in the Great Commission.
Conclusion
Evidence that Demands a Verdict is a classic work. The updated edition has done exactly what it should do: added new arguments, updated sources, and retained the positive qualities of the original.
This is a book that should be in church libraries, on the shelves of pastors, in the homes of Christian parents, and among the recommended resources for new believers.
Evidence That Demands a Verdict: Life-Changing Truth for a Skeptical World
By Josh McDowell, Sean McDowell
NOTE: I received a gratis copy of this volume with no expectation of a positive review.
Featured
How Can We Find Happiness?
How and How Not to Be Happy is an exercise in asking questions and reasoning through options for the source of happiness with the aim of explaining to a broad audience where true happiness can be found.
Can't Change the World? You Can Still Be Faithful.
Impossible Christianity isn’t DeYoung’s sexiest work. It is clearly and solidly written. It can be read in a couple of hours or subdivided to be consumed over a few days. It tends to be more sermonic than ground-breaking. Nevertheless, it is a good and helpful book.
This is the sort of book that would be a great gift for the struggling parent of young children wondering how the treadmill of dishes, laundry, activities, and meals could matter in eternity. This is the sort of book that can serve as a reminder to those who are not leading ministries that their contributions are vitally important. Impossible Christianity offers a kind word for those who are struggling to find meaning in the repetition of daily life. As such, it is a valuable book for the church.
How the West Got WEIRDER
For Americans the year 1776 has legendary status. It is, of course, the year that the Continental Congress declared the United States independent from the colonial power of Britian.
As it turns out, the year was actually globally significant in a number of other ways. The Industrial Revolution was getting into full swing, there were a number of significant philosophical movements afoot whose effects we are still discovering today.
Andrew Wilson’s book, Remaking the World: How 1776 Created the Post-Christian West is an attempt to bring many of those streams together to help explain how the world got turned upside down.
The Blessing of a Limited Life
Guardrails keep us on the pathway. They prevent us from falling off the cliff. They give us comfort that, though the paneling on our car may be damaged, if we slip on the icy road, yet we will not die.
A mountain road without those guardrails leaves us with a much greater fear. And that fear brings with it a greater pain. We experience that pain whether or not the worst happens, because we know there is a much higher likelihood that it will.
Education as Moral Formation
More than a decade into our home education experience, Macauley’s book fairly represents what we have been trying to do. I commend For the Children’s Sake to parents trying to figure out how to make a choice about educational methodologies. The Charlotte Mason approach is worth consideration, at least.
Macauley is realistic about the approach. She repeatedly notes areas in which she didn’t always get it right, because any educational process entails imperfect humans helping imperfect humans to learn. But she also provides illustrations of ways that her chosen approach can be self-correcting.
Freedom and the Costs of Technology
As a society, we need to think about the costs that technological expectations place on all of us. We need to think about how poor infrastructure exacts a permanent tax on each household. It may be that costly bike/walking trails and real bike lanes on roads could open up opportunities for reduced economic burdens in the long run. It may be that the cost of printing hard copies of things and not using the latest whizz-bang app could lower entry requirements for society.
School and Wonder at God's Creation
Whether we are studying the interaction of heavenly bodies, the multiplication tables, or the differences between a noun and a pronoun, we should never cease to consider the big picture. The God who created all things did so with order and continues to maintain the world in that order. Our response should be wonder at the works of his hands and a desire to understand his handiwork better.
Bavinck Helps Solve the Riddle of Life
I commend Bavinck’s The Riddle of Life as part of a homeschool curriculum, a youth discipleship study, or as a resource to study with a new believer. It would also be a good resource to study with someone who is considering Christianity for the first time.
What Is the Greatest Threat to the Church?
It would be interesting to see the results of a “person on the street” poll of self-identified evangelical Christians on the question, “What is the most significant threat to the church?”
I have a sneaking suspicion that the results would be much more indicative of the sources of media is most popular among the surveyed population than a real threat. Is the biggest threat CRT (are we even talking about that anymore?), “wokeism” (whatever that is), the effects of the sexual revolution, corporate greed and capitalism, political and social persecution of Christians, sexual abuse?
Love Never Fails, Even if Memories Do
This is a book that offers encouragement to those early in their Alzheimer’s journey. There is dignity for those who suffer from the malady. Subtly, Martin encourages readers to examine the assumption that we are our memories and that we cease to be who we are as a result of cognitive decline. Kathleen’s distinct personality remains with her to the end; that offers hope for all parties in the face of diagnosis.
About "Evidence That Demands a Verdict"
"Evidence That Demands a Verdict" is a well-known title in Christian apologetics, originally published in the early 1970s by Josh McDowell. The book has been recently updated and expanded by Josh McDowell and his son, Sean McDowell, who is an apologist serving on the faculty of Biola University. The book covers a wide range of topics related to the truthfulness of Christianity, including the historical reliability of Scripture, the historicity of Christ and his resurrection, the reliability of the Old Testament, and the possibility of truth in the context of postmodernism. The updated edition aims to provide new arguments, updated sources, and retain the positive qualities of the original, making it a valuable resource for Christians seeking to understand and defend the truth of Christianity [[SOURCE 1]].
Concepts in the Article
The article "Evidence That Demands a Verdict" discusses several concepts related to Christian apologetics and the updated edition of the book. These concepts include:
- Christian Apologetics: The book serves as a source book for Christian apologetics, presenting arguments and pointing readers toward more in-depth arguments for the truthfulness of Christianity.
- Historical Reliability of Scripture: The book invests five chapters discussing the historical reliability of Scripture.
- Historicity of Christ and His Resurrection: Eight chapters help demonstrate the historicity of Christ and his resurrection.
- Reliability of the Old Testament: The book includes thirteen chapters dedicated to the reliability of the Old Testament.
- Truth and Postmodernism: The book includes six chapters arguing that truth is possible, with an attempt to counter certain claims of postmodernism.
- Target Audience and Criticisms: The article discusses the target audience of the book, its brevity, and potential criticisms from Christian philosophers regarding some interpretations in the volume.
- Uses for the Book: It outlines the potential uses of the book, such as a reference book, for study with young Christians, and as a secondary volume in an apologetics course at the college or seminary level.
- Conclusion: The updated edition of the book has added new arguments, updated sources, and retained the positive qualities of the original, making it a classic work that should be in church libraries, on the shelves of pastors, in the homes of Christian parents, and among the recommended resources for new believers.
These concepts provide a comprehensive overview of the content and significance of "Evidence That Demands a Verdict" in the context of Christian apologetics and its relevance to the Christian community [[SOURCE 1]].
I hope this information provides a clear understanding of the concepts discussed in the article. If you have any further questions or need more details on any specific concept, feel free to ask!
