Midwestern Stromboli Pizza King Style - EverydayDonna's Recipe (2024)

Do you get tired of cooking sometimes? All the time? Never? Some of the above? None of the above? I love to cook, but sometimes on Friday evening I like to take a break and make something easy. We have had a guest staying with us for the last two weeks. By Friday evening, I was shot. I had been cooking up a storm and I needed a break, but of course we had to eat. So, I decided to make one of our favorites - strombolis.

Do you like strombolis? Ever had a stromboli? Don't confuse them with a calzone. They are not the same. We LOVE these sandwiches, but we like the midwestern style stromboli. We are from Evansville, Indiana, and there is a pizza shop that has been in operation as long as we have been married which is 43 years. Yeah, I know, forever. The shop is called Pizza King and my research showed that there are Pizza King's all over Indiana, but I could not find if they were franchised or owned by the same company or just had the same name. Looked like the original Pizza King started in northern Indiana somewhere. Interesting. Anyway, besides awesome pizza they have fabulous sandwiches - hot ham and cheese, strombolis, and Texas barbecue. They are always wrapped in aluminum foil and baked. You can get the stroms and Texas barbecues anywhere from mild to "blow the top of your head off" hot. But, they are SOOOOOOOO good. I miss them here in good old Nashville. So, what did I do but create my own. Sure, why not?

Here is a little history on the stromboli. They are an American sandwich (which we all think is Italian, but isn't) usually made in a pizza type dough with Italian meats and cheese, layered and rolled, baked and then sliced. Midwestern style strombolis are not like that. They are made in a crusty roll like a baguette, or on a deli style roll which is what I used. Mine has sausage, pepperoni, onions, marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese. Mmmm, mmmm, mmmm, delicious.

Why are they called strombolis? Good question. Here is what Wikipedia has to say.

A stromboli is made with a square shaped pizza dough that can be topped with any pizza toppings and is then rolled into a log and baked. Many American pizza shops serve a stromboli using pizza dough that is folded in half with fillings, similar to acalzone.

There are some theories regarding the origin of the stromboli in the United States. Romano's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria claims to have originated it in 1950 inEssington,Tinicum Township, just outside ofPhiladelphia, by Nazzareno Romano. According to Romano, a friend suggested he name it after the then recently released movie,Stromboli.[1]Another claim is that the stromboli was invented in 1954 by Mike Aquino at Mike's Burger Royale in Spokane, Washington. Aquino is also supposed to have named the sandwich after the movie.

So, we don't really know exactly where this sandwich originated, we just know we are happy that it originated somewhere even though ours isn't made this way. Ha! Now, about making these delicious sandwiches. They are really super easy and I guess you could use your favorite ingredients, but here is how I made mine which is very close to the Pizza King stromboli. Here is what you need.

1 pound milk bulk sausage
1 pound hot Italian sausage (casing removed if using links)
1 large onion, diced
2 cloves garlic, minced
1 cup of your favorite marinara sauce (I used Trader Joe's tomato basil)
about 30 pepperonis chopped (stack and chop, makes it easier)
1 8 ounce block mozzarella cheese, grated
3 tsp crushed red pepper flakes
6 deli type rolls
olive oil
6 sheets of aluminum foil, about 12-14 inches long

1 baking sheet

Brown the sausages and onions in a saute' pan. Drain any fat from the pan. Add the garlic and chopped pepperoni when the sausage is browned. Add the marinara sauce and red pepper flakes. Stir until thoroughly mixed and heated through.

Brush the top and bottom of a deli roll with some good olive oil. Put the sliced deli roll in the middle of a piece of foil, fill with sausage mixture. Put several heaping hands full of cheese on the sausage. Bring the edges of the foil together and roll down to the sandwich and roll the ends up.

When all the rolls have been filled and wrapped, place them on a baking sheet and bake in a 350 degree oven for about 20-30 minutes. Remove from the oven and let cool for a few minutes. Unwrap and enjoy.

There was enough meat left for another 6 strombolis. It could easily be frozen and used another time. I used it in a bolognese sauce later in the week. Yum.

This sandwich is "just right" spicy as Dan said. Not too hot, not too mild. Goldilocks would approve. Look at all that yumminess. If you like really spicy food, use all hot sausage and add all the red pepper flakes you want. If you like bell peppers, add some to the sausage mix while cooking. You can add what you like, it's your choice but this is the traditional "Evansville" way.

When the strombolis are unwrapped, the rolls will be crusty and crunchy on the outside and the filling is spicy and cheesy good. So easy, so good. If you have never had one, now is the time to try making these.

The West Side Nut Club sponsors THE Fall Festival in Evansville every year during the first full week of October. (Google it, it's so interesting) There are hundreds of food booths which all raise money for non profits. Thousands of people attend every year. One of the most popular booths year after year consistently is the Tau Kappa Epsilon Stromboli booth from the University of Southern Indiana. Everyone is willing to stand in line for some time just to snag a few of their delicious strombolis which are made this way. Many people go day after day during the week to eat these stroms because they just can't get enough. Now, you don't have to wait until the first week of October, or even have to go out to Pizza King to enjoy one of these fabulous sandwiches. Wait, what am I thinking? You may not have anywhere that makes this type stromboli. If you don't live in Indiana, if you don't have a Pizza King, you can now make your own extraordinary midwestern style stromboli. Now you will know what you have been missing all these years. Enjoy!

Everyday Donna

Things to Remember:

Every region of the country has their own food specialties that you grow accustomed to and love. This is one of ours. What is something you love from your area? donna

Midwestern Stromboli Pizza King Style - EverydayDonna's Recipe (2024)

FAQs

What is in a pizza king stromboli? ›

Zesty sausage, cheese, onions, & tomato sauce.

What sandwich is similar to a stromboli? ›

Calzones and stromboli are variations on a pizza theme: both are made with pizza or bread dough and stuffed with cheese. And both lend themselves to creative customization with fillings made up of different cheeses and toppings.

How do you cook a giant food store stromboli? ›

Cooking instructions: Place Stromboli on pan seam side down. Bake in preheated 400 F oven for approx 20 min (until crust is golden). Keep refrigerated.

What cheese does Pizza King use? ›

Our pizzas start with fresh dough made daily at each location. We then top it with our signature pizza sauce that is made from fresh packed vine ripened sweet California tomatoes. We finish with a Wisconsin 100% whole milk mozzarella cheese that is allowed to age to our specifications and then hand shredded.

What's the difference between a calzone and a stromboli recipe? ›

Calzones usually contain the same ingredients as pizza: tomato sauce, mozzarella, and (almost always) ricotta. Stromboli is typically made without ricotta. Most chefs prefer to use just low-moisture mozzarella to keep moisture at bay.

Is a calzone the same as a stromboli with ricotta? ›

Calzones use ricotta cheese, and stromboli does not. Stromboli is made with mozzarella cheese (preferably low-moisture) to keep moisture at a minimum. This helps the interior dough cook fully. Calzones usually use a blend of cheese that almost always incorporates ricotta.

What to serve with stromboli? ›

What to Serve with Stromboli. Stromboli is a bit heavy with all that meat and cheese, so make sure to lighten up your plate with a simple side salad, or if you're feeling ambitious, go all out with an Antipasto Salad. You can even use some of the ingredients in the Antipasto inside of your stromboli!

Where were stromboli invented? ›

ORIGINS. The story of the stromboli goes back to 1950s Philadelphia, where a restaurant owner by the name of Nazzareno Romano is known to have started selling a rolled up pizza dough filled with ham, cheese, and peppers. Stromboli is often confused with another dish called calzone – so how are they different?

Who makes frozen stromboli? ›

Leonetti´s insistence on perfection is what makes our Handmade Stromboli a favorite for families across the nation. Baked at our factory, right here in Philly, and then immediately fresh frozen to maintain all the freshness, guaranteeing excellence each and every time. All you have to do is heat and eat.

How do you cook Leonetti's stromboli? ›

You make three holes in the wrapper, leave wrappe ron.. 365 degrees for 25-30 minutes if frozen... If cooking from thawed everything is the same but only cook 15-20 minutes.. use a cookie sheet.

How to cook martins stromboli? ›

Remove product from package and place on baking sheet on center rack of oven. Heat for 12-15 minutes (Oven/Microwave temperature & times may vary from equipment to equipment), until center is warm and reaches 160 degrees F. Microwave: Place product on microwaveable dish and heat for 1-1/2 minutes.

How do you reheat a pizza King stromboli? ›

A stromboli is a type of turnover, similar to an Italian calzone. Because of the outer bread/flour crust it has, I think microwaving it will make it moist and watery. Rather, place it on a cooking sheet and bake it for 10–12 minutes at around 300–325 degrees in a regular oven.

What is the difference between a stromboli and a pizza turnover? ›

A calzone is a folded over piece of pizza dough with various fillings. The final result has a pocket. With a stromboli you start with a rolled out rectangular shaped piece of pizza dough which gets fillings spread out over it and then it is rolled up more tightly. Stromboli ends up with layers of the dough throughout.

What's the difference between a calzone and a stromboli Reddit? ›

To the best of my knowledge, Stromboli is rolled up to create layers on the interior in an almost spiraled fashion, whereas Calzones are large pockets, much like an empanada, without layering on the inside.

What's in a stromboli calzone? ›

Strombolis also have a signature filling of ham, mozzarella, and tomato sauce, while calzone fillings have always varied throughout history. In essence, strombolis are more akin to chopped-up pizza "burritos," whereas calzones are sealed pizza "tacos" meant for one.

What is the biggest pizza at Pizza King? ›

Your classic ,thin style, Pizza King pizza cut in our easy-to-share square pieces. Available in: Personal (8″) Small (10″), Medium (12″), Large (14″), and XL (16″) sizes. If you prefer a thicker crust, try our pan pizza.

Is a pepperoni roll same as a stromboli? ›

Pepperoni bread (aka pepperoni roll or stromboli) has always been a special treat for me. In my Italian family in southern New Jersey, we all savored pepperoni bread! This recipe makes enough dough for 2 loaves of pepperoni bread (you'll have to double the fillings though).

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Melvina Ondricka

Last Updated:

Views: 6125

Rating: 4.8 / 5 (48 voted)

Reviews: 95% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Melvina Ondricka

Birthday: 2000-12-23

Address: Suite 382 139 Shaniqua Locks, Paulaborough, UT 90498

Phone: +636383657021

Job: Dynamic Government Specialist

Hobby: Kite flying, Watching movies, Knitting, Model building, Reading, Wood carving, Paintball

Introduction: My name is Melvina Ondricka, I am a helpful, fancy, friendly, innocent, outstanding, courageous, thoughtful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.